Nonprofit Executive Search & Transition
FIND LEADERS WHO CAN ADVANCE YOUR MISSION AND STRENGTHEN YOUR ORGANIZATION.
Selecting your next leader is a critical decision and an opportunity for strategic realignment.

Executive transitions are both promising and vulnerable times. We help nonprofits use search to align their strategic priorities with the skills and attributes of their next leader—while supporting a successful transition.

Our comprehensive approach will clarify your organization’s needs, create an inclusive and transparent process, and identify qualified candidates who understand your mission and community, can execute your strategic vision, and strengthen your internal capacity. We can also work with your outgoing or interim leadership and board to support organizational stability and the successful onboarding of your new leader.

Our goal is to help you emerge from this transition stronger and more aligned than ever before.

What makes Fio different from most nonprofit executive search firms?
We have deep sector knowledge across the nonprofit landscape, with regional expertise in Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island.
Our strategic planning background provides a unique perspective on institutional needs and leadership requirements.
We have a trust-based reputation built primarily through word-of-mouth referrals from over 500 organizations nationwide.
Get right-fit support to find your right-fit candidate.
Whether you just need help building a targeted candidate pool, want a comprehensive process, or something in between, Fio can tailor our level of support to meet your needs.
Executive Search & Transition Services

We’ll build a targeted candidate pool based on your existing job description. We identify prospects through research and professional networks, then conduct initial outreach to gauge interest.

Ideal for leadership positions reporting to senior staff.

Get comprehensive search support, including candidate screening, initial interviews, and detailed candidate profiles. We ensure only the most qualified candidates advance while managing logistics throughout the process.

Ideal for senior leaders reporting to the CEO/ED.

A custom engagement tailored to your strategic objectives. We assess organizational needs, develop optimized position descriptions, provide market compensation data, manage the entire recruitment lifecycle, support your search committee, and create transition plans for long-term success.

Ideal for CEO/Executive Director searches.

Fio’s Executive & Leadership Search Process
Designed around your specific needs and stage of development, we tailor each engagement to your unique timeline, budget, and scope.
Organizational Assessment & Strategy Alignment

We start by understanding your stage of development, strategic priorities, and the leadership attributes that will drive success. This includes assessing financial health and operational readiness, as well as gathering input from your board and staff.

Core Resources include: Basic Organizational Assessment, Financial Health Indicators, Board and Senior Staff Input

Search Committee Support & Process Design

Together, we craft an optimized position description, determine the appropriate compensation, and form a search committee that reflects the diversity of your community.

Core Resources include: Search Facilitation, Position Profile, Salary Benchmarks

Recruitment & Candidate Screening

Fio uses “push and pull” strategies to ensure your position reaches candidates that meet your criteria, and we develop candidate screening criteria and rating sheets to ensure consistent evaluation.

Core Resources include: Job Posting, Professional Recruiting, Candidate Screening, and Initial Assessment

Candidate Selection & Interview Support

We provide comprehensive candidate screening, interview support, and facilitation of the decision-making process. You’ll receive detailed insights on each candidate, along with confidence in your final selection.

Core Resources include: Candidate Reports, Interview Materials, Search Committee Support

Transition Planning & Onboarding Support

Throughout the process, Fio Partners will work with your outgoing or interim leadership and the board to support internal stability and the successful onboarding of your new leadership. The amount and type of support needed will be unique to every situation. We establish success metrics and evaluation plans for the new leader’s first year.

Core Resources include: Relationship Mapping, Onboarding Guide, and Briefing Book for the new executive.

“Our organization has experienced substantial growth with our new Executive Director at the helm. We had a very positive experience working with Fio in the Search, and the results have been transformative.”
CEPHUS NOLAN, Board Member, Amplify
We’re your partners in executive search.

Since 2007, we’ve worked alongside nonprofit leaders as they face their most critical decisions. Having advised over 500 organizations through strategic planning, mergers, leadership transitions, and more, we’ve seen firsthand how exemplary leadership can transform your trajectory.

Our role is to guide you through a process that gives you confidence in both the search itself and your final selection. We’ll help you feel prepared, not overwhelmed, because we know how to break down the process into manageable, thoughtful steps.

FAQs

Pricing is based on the complexity of the position, the size of the organization, the age of the strategic plan, as well as the tools and activities required for a successful engagement. We’ll work with your organization to tailor a search engagement appropriate for your budget.

We treat search as an organizational development and a strategic opportunity. Our process involves assessing organizational health, understanding your stage of development, and ensuring that your next leader can effectively execute your strategic vision. We’re facilitators who help you make informed decisions through inclusive, collaborative processes.

Executive searches typically take 3-6 months, depending on position complexity and organizational readiness. Leadership positions may move faster. We work within your timeline while ensuring thoroughness and attention to detail.

Our process is designed to understand exactly what you’re looking for before we begin recruiting. We screen candidates thoroughly and provide detailed profiles so you know why each person advances. If needed, we expand the search until you’re confident in your choice.

We handle the logistics while keeping you involved in key decisions. Board involvement typically includes participation on the search committee and conducting final candidate interviews. Staff input is gathered early in the process to inform what you’re looking for in your next leader.

While we have deep expertise in the New England nonprofit landscape, we work with organizations nationwide. Our process adapts to your regional context and community relationships.